Geeksbury
Edgar Allan Poe Short Stories

STORY REVIEW: The Duc De L’Omelette

Edgar Allan Poe

Devil playing cards” by Crossett Library Bennington College is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 2.0.

First Things First…

I just reviewed my first Poe story last week, and now I’m about to get to my second. It’s another one I’ve never heard of, so I have no idea what it’s about. I didn’t love “Metzengerstein” last week. And looking ahead at the Table of Contents in my Poe complete collection, it’s going to be a little while before I get to any of his famous works. So hopefully some of these more obscure ones—like this—are enjoyable.


2 Things I Like


2. Playing Cards with the Devil

The premise is solid. A nobleman dies, goes to Hell, and plays cards with the Devil to win his soul back.

So far, so good…

1. No Fear

“’Sir!’ replied the Duc, ‘I am not to be insulted with impunity!—Sir! I shall take the earliest opportunity of avenging this insult!—Sir! You shall hear from me! In the meantime au revoir!’”

The Duc De L’Omelette

When the Duc first discovers where he is and who he’s talking to, it doesn’t seem to intimidate him. He’s still arrogant enough to talk shit to the Devil.

Granted, he becomes more fearful when he looks out the window and sees the hellscape beyond. And he hears melodies that he realizes are really “the wailings and the howlings of the hopeless and the damned!”

But none of it scares him away from cheating at cards and escaping damnation.


0 Things I’m Mixed On


1 Thing I Don’t Like

1. Footnotes & French

This story is only three pages, but it has close to 10 French phrases I had to look up, not to mention even more allusions to art, history, and other works of his day that required footnotes. And even once I was able to fill in the blanks, the references didn’t resonate with me.

The Review

37%

This is a very short review for a very short story. Sadly, I don't have much to say about it.

Despite the cool premise, there was no way for me to enjoy this. For something so short, it took way too much effort to read. In fact, I unquestionably liked “Metzengerstein” more than this.

 According to Wikipedia, this is intended as a satire on the works of Nathaniel Parker Willis.

Who? What? What exactly is that supposed to mean to me?

Obviously this was intended for audiences of its time. I think it just hasn't aged well. But after this, I really hope one of Poe’s next stories hits for me.

37%
Skip to toolbar